Hmm...restricted posts still show up on blog page...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
Okay, I'm confused. I'm using Thesis as my theme, and I have setup the membership plugin to provide access to specific information, but I've run into something that is confusing me.
If I restrict a post, then log-out, the post can still be seen in the main blog feed. If I click on the post, I am directed to the membership notification page, which I created.
My understanding would be that all posts that are restricted wouldn't show up on the blog page, whether the reading settings in Wordpress are set to a static page/post page or the main feed.
Neither cases produce the desired results.
How do I completely hide posts based on security settings?
If {user level is whatever} then display this post in the feed, else, don't.
If I restrict a post, then log-out, the post can still be seen in the main blog feed. If I click on the post, I am directed to the membership notification page, which I created.
My understanding would be that all posts that are restricted wouldn't show up on the blog page, whether the reading settings in Wordpress are set to a static page/post page or the main feed.
Neither cases produce the desired results.
How do I completely hide posts based on security settings?
If {user level is whatever} then display this post in the feed, else, don't.