"Unable to verify" error but works with paypal generated but
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
I'm getting the "Unable to verify POST vars"... have done all the troubleshooting I can based on other tickets.
If i generate the button from paypal it works fine, but when using the plugin I get the error, all settings are quadruple checked.
I downloaded these files curl-test-http-google.php
curl-test-https-paypal.php
fopen-test-https-paypal.php
and all three brought up blank white pages. Does this contradict the fact that everything works fine when using a paypal generated button?
If i generate the button from paypal it works fine, but when using the plugin I get the error, all settings are quadruple checked.
I downloaded these files curl-test-http-google.php
curl-test-https-paypal.php
fopen-test-https-paypal.php
and all three brought up blank white pages. Does this contradict the fact that everything works fine when using a paypal generated button?