Mis(re)direction when accessing protected file
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
I've searched the forum and did not see where my exact problem was addressed...sorry if I missed something.
When I attempt to access protected content (in this case: http://www...., I am redirected to the home page, and not to the page I have set as the Membership Options page on my site (http://www....).
Am I missing something painfully obvious here? Any suggestions would be appreciated as to why my saved setting is being overridden. Thanks.
When I attempt to access protected content (in this case: http://www...., I am redirected to the home page, and not to the page I have set as the Membership Options page on my site (http://www....).
Am I missing something painfully obvious here? Any suggestions would be appreciated as to why my saved setting is being overridden. Thanks.