Security badge won't verify, what am I missing
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
Hello all, please understand that I have read all of the posts and have checked my installation before posting, but I am obviously missing something. Below are screenshots and steps of what I have done. Please advise.
[*]created security key under general options using "auto-generate" - resulted in a 64 character code - then saved all
[*]Enabled security badge status API - saved all changes
[*]Ensured my wp-config.php has 4 - 60 or more characters of jibberish in the salt/stuff area
[*]Changed brute force attack to 4 attempts and selected "reset" - then saved all changes
[*]Ensured that Unique IP is enabled and changed lockout time to 1 hour then "reset" - then saved all changes
I just don't know what else to do. I have read the posts on this site and most people made the mistale of not having enough characters in their encryption keys. I have checked the two places where those go, 1. in the s2member setup (which is auto generated and I didi count the characters just to make sure) and 2. in the wordpress wp-config.php file. All 4 keys are longer then 60 characters. It is probably something dumb that I am overlooking but I can't waste anymore time trying to find it on my own. I need help. Thank you in advance, I know together we can solve it.
[*]created security key under general options using "auto-generate" - resulted in a 64 character code - then saved all
[*]Enabled security badge status API - saved all changes
[*]Ensured my wp-config.php has 4 - 60 or more characters of jibberish in the salt/stuff area
[*]Changed brute force attack to 4 attempts and selected "reset" - then saved all changes
[*]Ensured that Unique IP is enabled and changed lockout time to 1 hour then "reset" - then saved all changes
I just don't know what else to do. I have read the posts on this site and most people made the mistale of not having enough characters in their encryption keys. I have checked the two places where those go, 1. in the s2member setup (which is auto generated and I didi count the characters just to make sure) and 2. in the wordpress wp-config.php file. All 4 keys are longer then 60 characters. It is probably something dumb that I am overlooking but I can't waste anymore time trying to find it on my own. I need help. Thank you in advance, I know together we can solve it.