Level 0 Members gaining access to Login Welcome Page
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
I have Simple:Press set up as well as S2Member. S2M is handling the logins well. However, I set up a test subscriber account to check various pages and options. This forum member account, Level 0 is gaining access to the Login Welcome Page, which I renamed Premium. I use it as a hub, or homepage for premium content. None of the content is accessible to the forum member account, just the Login Welcome page.
It doesn't seem to matter whether the test account is logged in via the forum or via the premium login url - it still gains access to the Login Welcome page.
This page is automatically protected, how can a level 0 see it ? I've only set up level 1 as a premium option through the paypal options etc. Does S2M know to apply level 1 automatically?
Am I doing something wrong?
It doesn't seem to matter whether the test account is logged in via the forum or via the premium login url - it still gains access to the Login Welcome page.
This page is automatically protected, how can a level 0 see it ? I've only set up level 1 as a premium option through the paypal options etc. Does S2M know to apply level 1 automatically?
Am I doing something wrong?