URI Restrictions not working (seemingly)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
Well, I watched the many setup videos, read many posts about URI's here and finally decided it was time to either redeem my busted pride or discover a a hereto unknown bug. I cannot for the life of me get the URI restriction boxes to work. I'm running the latest of s2member Pro and here's the setup:
Original URL for Level 2 members:
www.mysite.com/directory/zone/awesomestuff/catface.gif
"URIs That Require Level #2 Or Higher" box set to:
/zone/
Everything nicely setup as intended and looks good but when I do a test (as a non logged in person). I can still go directly to:
www.mysite.com/directory/zone/awesomestuff/catface.gif
OK - I accept my shame and at this point admit it must be something blazingly simple. I await my answer but continue to work on the issue!
Original URL for Level 2 members:
www.mysite.com/directory/zone/awesomestuff/catface.gif
"URIs That Require Level #2 Or Higher" box set to:
/zone/
Everything nicely setup as intended and looks good but when I do a test (as a non logged in person). I can still go directly to:
www.mysite.com/directory/zone/awesomestuff/catface.gif
OK - I accept my shame and at this point admit it must be something blazingly simple. I await my answer but continue to work on the issue!