Redirect broken member options page
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
If a user in not logged in and they try and access http://tvta.ca/members-only/ the redirection to the member options page works.
If a user is logged in with membership level 0 or level 1 all I see is a blank page when I try and access that page. Nothing loads.
http://tvta.ca/members-only/membership- ... er_seeking[type]=page&_s2member_seeking[page]=414&_s2member_seeking[_uri]=L21lbWJlcnMtb25seS8%3D&_s2member_req[type]=level&_s2member_req[level]=1&_s2member_res[type]=page&s2member_seeking=page-414&s2member_level_req=1
WordPress 3.2.1
Secure WordPress Version 2.0.7
Wordpress Firewall 2 Version 1.3
WP Security Scan Version 3.0.9
If a user is logged in with membership level 0 or level 1 all I see is a blank page when I try and access that page. Nothing loads.
http://tvta.ca/members-only/membership- ... er_seeking[type]=page&_s2member_seeking[page]=414&_s2member_seeking[_uri]=L21lbWJlcnMtb25seS8%3D&_s2member_req[type]=level&_s2member_req[level]=1&_s2member_res[type]=page&s2member_seeking=page-414&s2member_level_req=1
WordPress 3.2.1
Secure WordPress Version 2.0.7
Wordpress Firewall 2 Version 1.3
WP Security Scan Version 3.0.9