Question About Changing Level 1 PayPal Button Pri
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
Some months ago created a PayPal button short code in S2Member for level 1 membership at $7.
Last night I created a new PayPayl button short code in S2M for $19 for level 1 membership.
Sooo, my question is, will the $19 apply ONLY to new members who join and existing members at level 1 will continue at $7 per month?-(that's what I want, members who are in now should stay at $7, only new members should be charged $19).
OR - do I need to create a new button in a different level in order to achieve this?
THANKS! : )
David
Last night I created a new PayPayl button short code in S2M for $19 for level 1 membership.
Sooo, my question is, will the $19 apply ONLY to new members who join and existing members at level 1 will continue at $7 per month?-(that's what I want, members who are in now should stay at $7, only new members should be charged $19).
OR - do I need to create a new button in a different level in order to achieve this?
THANKS! : )
David