protect blog with different static homepage
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
I've set a static page as my homepage and the blog as another page on the site. I want to make the blog members only. When I test it, I am able to access the blog "page" without logging in. When tested on other pages (non-blog) it protects them just fine. Suggestions?