NOT WORKING WITH MULTI-CATEGORIES
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
Hi.
I have defined protected category (free-recipes-for-members), so all fine when accessing:
/category/free-recipes-for-members/
The problem starts when listing a 2nd category. If a post is on free-recipes-for-members and that 2nd category it is displayed on the listdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d8c6/1d8c64b94a4c44473b3a795f302f521d0184de38" alt="Sad :("
How can I fix it?
All seems to be OK when trying to access that single post - I am taken into the MEMBERS login page.
Believe it is the same problem with search results and RSS?
I have defined protected category (free-recipes-for-members), so all fine when accessing:
/category/free-recipes-for-members/
The problem starts when listing a 2nd category. If a post is on free-recipes-for-members and that 2nd category it is displayed on the list
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d8c6/1d8c64b94a4c44473b3a795f302f521d0184de38" alt="Sad :("
How can I fix it?
All seems to be OK when trying to access that single post - I am taken into the MEMBERS login page.
Believe it is the same problem with search results and RSS?