Post/Page restriction not working (local issue?)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc6a/8cc6a0afd8b00a71bdcdf9d0c082954ddf2d4b25" alt="Post Post"
I'm running into a problem where all pages and posts are being displayed when they shouldn't be. I have pages and posts restriction both set to "all" - I did confirm that a "membership" page is set and defined in the settings. I tried to access the site with another browser (to make sure it didn't see me as logged in) - and all pages and posts are displayed (not restricted). I was testing this out on a local copy of WordPress using the new default theme (twenty ten) - no other plugins are running.
Does this plugin have any known issues running on a locally hosted copy of WordPress (I'm running MAMP)
Thanks in advance for any help!
-Jennifer
Does this plugin have any known issues running on a locally hosted copy of WordPress (I'm running MAMP)
Thanks in advance for any help!
-Jennifer